The unapologetic,
unashamed,
unmistakable
taste of
Pilgrims Choice.

THE RANGE

From flavour that will make your hair stand on
end, to cheese that won’t hurt your waistline,
Pilgrims Choice has got it all.

PILGRIMS CHOICE EXTRA MATURE

Break off a chunk and get that rich and creamy, smooth taste. The crunch? That’s the calcium lactate crystals formed as it’s aged, we hand-select all our cheese to ensure its delivers in every bite.

PILGRIMS CHOICE MATURE

Imagine a cheese so smooth, so moreish and so undeniably good that it’s hard to put down. Hand-selected for a long-lasting flavour, this cheddar hits the spot time and again. Ready to cancel the bland and bring unrivalled flavour to your meals?

PILGRIMS CHOICE VINTAGE

Become a cheeseboard champ with the robust, long-lasting flavour. A crunchy and sweet cheese that lives long in the memory and can turn bitesize snacking into profound, flavour-packed experiences.

PILGRIMS CHOICE GRATED EXTRA MATURE

Bye Bye bland. Why hello, flavour! A rich and creamy cheese that brings a new meaning to mouth watering, meal making flavour. Get ready to make those dishes dance! An unforgettable flavour you can’t live without.

PILGRIMS CHOICE SLICED EXTRA MATURE

Transform lunchtime, boost your burgers and make your sarnies sing. A rich and creamy cheddar that can turn toasties into bubbling works of art. Take a slice of the action.

PILGRIMS CHOICE LIGHTER EXTRA MATURE

It may be lighter, but don’t be fooled! Satisfy those cheesy needs with its silky smooth, long-lasting taste. Watch this moreish cheese melt into your pasta bake, top those spuds and enhance your lunch time game… just with 30% less fat

PILGRIMS CHOICE LIGHTER MATURE

30% less fat, but still delivers knock-out flavour. Lighter extra mature is rich and creamy to revolutionise your omelettes and add oomph into every meal. We don’t compromise on taste!

PILGRIMS CHOICE CARAMELISED ONION

The British may be reserved, but our taste in cheese isn’t. To tickle the most curious palates we’ve taken our creamy mature cheddar one big step further with intense caramelised onion. It’s a sweet and tangy marvel readymade to knock your taste buds for six.

PILGRIMS CHOICE HOT HONEY

This hot new classic knocks it out of the park. It takes our famously smooth mature cheddar and adds some serious americana – hot honey, jalapeño, and paprika. Just sprinkle on your mac ‘n cheese for a home run!

PILGRIMS CHOICE SMOKY PAPRIKA

Now you can pimp up not just your nachos…But kinda anything… With our smoky, creamy Mexican cheddar. Bringing even more paprika, onion & tomato to every mouthful…Share the extra smokiness with your amigos!

PILGRIMS CHOICE GARLIC AND HERB

When it comes to classic Italian combinations, more definitely more. We’ve added basil, garlic & herbs to this creamy mature cheddar. So, turn your next lasagna into a grande family lunch to remember!